Your Gift is Doubled When You Save Babies with PreBorn!

Democrats call for nationwide data center moratorium; critics push back

Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

(The Center Square) – Democratic lawmakers and environmental advocates continued calls Tuesday for a nationwide moratorium on data center construction until Congress adopts federal regulations addressing data center development and artificial intelligence.


Speakers raised concerns about data centers’ effects on local utility bills, water supplies and energy demand, which they warned could prolong reliance on fossil fuels. They also cited concerns about Big Tech, land use and AI companies’ ability to control their technology and prevent its misuse.


U.S. Rep. Jim McGovern, D-Mass., pointed to the series of widespread technical outages over the past week affecting major companies, as well as the Federal Aviation Administration and National Security Agency, as examples of why greater oversight of AI is needed, although he acknowledged that their connection to the technology remains unclear.


“We’re all seeing the headlines in real time about cyber incidents in the last few days. We don't even know which of these is related to AI,” McGovern said. “We are here because the alarm bells are flashing, and the president and the White House are asleep at the switch when it comes to AI.”


McGovern noted that the Trump administration had reduced the workforce of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, which helps protect the nation's critical infrastructure against cyberattacks and other threats, by roughly 30%. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin has since discussed plans to rebuild the agency's workforce, though lawmakers have questioned how those plans align with reported staffing cuts in the administration's proposed fiscal year 2027 budget.


McGovern cosponsored legislation introduced by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., in June called the AI Data Center Moratorium Act, which would halt new development pending federal AI regulations.


Rep. Chellie Pingree, D-Maine, praised efforts in her state to restrict data center development. Maine lawmakers passed a statewide moratorium on large data centers earlier this year, but Democratic Gov. Janet Mills vetoed the measure. Mills subsequently established an advisory council to study the industry's impacts.


Pingree also criticized the Trump administration's consideration of proposals to develop data centers and related infrastructure on nearly 18,000 acres of federal public lands across six Western states. She called for a ban on the sale of public lands for that purpose.


“These lands are national treasures that belong to the American public. They do not belong to tech billionaires,” she added.


Underlying the calls for a moratorium is a broader question of whether communities have enough information to assess the consequences of data center development before projects are approved.


Jim Walsh, policy director for Food & Water Watch, said communities often lack a clear understanding of the demands large data centers could place on local resources.


“They don't understand, and it's impossible for them to understand the impacts that a massive hyperscale data center will have on existing water resources,” Walsh said. "This will give them time to actually understand the impacts of these massive projects on communities and decide if they are actually appropriate, not when they are appropriate."


Though hesitant to endorse a nationwide moratorium, Michael Kiparsky, director of the Wheeler Water Institute at the University of California, Berkeley, agreed that communities frequently lack the information necessary to weigh the costs and benefits of data center development.


“I can understand why there would be calls for a moratorium. However, given the degree to which data centers are integrated into the fabric of our lives, it would seem like a nationwide moratorium is perhaps a blunt instrument,” Kiparsky told The Center Square.


He advocated requirements to ensure communities receive clear information and guidance about the local and regional costs and benefits of proposed data centers before approving development.


Kiparsky expressed particular concern about smaller and rural communities, which can lack the technical expertise and resources to evaluate developments of this scale. Local officials must consider not only how much water a proposed data center would consume, but whether existing water and wastewater systems could accommodate its needs, how demand might fluctuate and what the long-term implications could be for local supplies.


But he also emphasized that communities of all sizes, regardless of their resources, are struggling to assess the combined impacts of data center development.


“Nobody has seen this before. Nobody knows how to handle this kind of expansion at a national or regional scale,” Kiparsky said.


The Data Center Coalition, an industry trade association, argued that a nationwide moratorium would overlook the essential role data centers play in modern life while jeopardizing economic opportunities for communities.


“Data centers power modern life — from telehealth and digital classrooms to banking, air travel, financial transactions, and online shopping,” said Michele Nellenbach, the coalition's vice president of federal affairs, in a statement shared with The Center Square. “With the average household using more than 20 connected devices, this infrastructure is not optional; it is foundational.”


Nellenbach argued that restrictions could cost communities jobs, tax revenue and long-term investment, particularly in rural and industrial areas seeking economic development. She also said the industry is committed to responsible water and energy use and to paying the full cost of the electricity its facilities consume.


“The data center industry remains committed to working with communities, local officials, and state and federal leaders to ensure the continued responsible development of this critical industry while protecting families and businesses,” she said.

 

Salem News Channel Today

Sponsored Links

On Air & Up Next

  • The Scott Jennings Show
    11:00AM - 12:00PM
     
    Jennings is battle-tested on cable news, a veteran of four presidential   >>
     
  • The Hugh Hewitt Show
    12:00PM - 3:00PM
     
    Hugh Hewitt is one of the nation’s leading bloggers and a genuine media   >>
     
  • The Larry Elder Show
    3:00PM - 6:00PM
     
    Larry Elder personifies the phrase “We’ve Got a Country to Save” The “Sage from   >>
     
  • SEKULOW
    6:00PM - 7:00PM
     
    Logan Sekulow and Will Haynes are joined by Jordan Sekulow to discuss Justice   >>
     
  • The Mike Gallagher Show
    7:00PM - 10:00PM
     
    Please Welcome Joey Hudson, Who is Guest-Hosting for Mike Gallagher Today! Find   >>
     

See the Full Program Guide